Showing posts with label The Romance of Tristan and Iseult. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Romance of Tristan and Iseult. Show all posts

Sunday, March 7

Book Review: The Romance of Tristan and Iseult by Joseph Bédier



Author: Joseph Bédier, Hilaire Belloc (Translator)
Title: The Romance of Tristan and Iseult
Genre: Romance, Fantasy, Classics
Format: paperback
Pages: 205 
Published: 1170
Where I Got It: My shelf (Used bookstore)



Summary: 
This immortal tale from the Age of Chivalry concerns the doomed love between a knight and a princess — one of the great romances of medieval literature, along with that of Lancelot and Guinevere. The heroic Tristan, nephew and champion of King Mark of Cornwall, journeys to Ireland to bring home his uncle's betrothed, the fair Iseult. Their shipboard voyage takes a tumultuous turn with a misunderstanding and a magic potion, and the lovers quickly find that there's no turning back.

An enduring theme in Western art, literature, and music, Tristan and Iseult's tragic tale was most famously interpreted by Richard Wagner in his popular opera. This edition features J. Bédier's seamless weaving of many medieval sources into a captivating narrative, complemented by Hilaire Belloc's eloquent translation.


Review:
"Love pressed them hard, as thirst presses the dying stag to the stream; love dropped upon them from high heaven, as a hawk slipped after long hunger falls right upon the bird. And love will not be hidden...But in every hour and place every man could see Love terrible, that rode them, and could see in these lovers their every sense overflowing like new wine working in the vat."

Yayy re-reading this for the year. It was picked for book club so I dusted this bad boy off and gave it another read. The last time I read this was in 3/10/2015. *does math* Pretty much 6 years to the day (odd...very odd and kinda funny). 

This is for sure a little hard to read. It is old English much like a lot of the classics. But I enjoy it so much. Its a quick read, but SO much happens to these love birds. There are a lot of interpretations of the original poem. This is just one of them. I would love to read the original in the original language, but I would have to learn that language first. Sighs. Dreams and goals one day. 

This breaks my heart every time I read it. Not just for Tristan and Iseult the Fair, but for King Mark. WHY didn't they just leave him alone. He was FINE not marrying. He didn't WANT to marry. The Councillors hated Tristan SO much that they didn't want him to possibly inherit. They doomed all of them. Yes, yes, this is supposed to be a tragedy and all, but SIGHS it always pisses me off. 

Lies lead into more lies. Leads into doing whatever you can to keep the secret, which just makes it worse. It is tragic for everyone involved. It's a sad story from the moment they sip from that cup. 

I love the magic and fantasy elements mixed in (not the magic love potion though. UGH). The movie really avoided that...which I get....but I think it added an little something extra to the story. You can't fight magic. I didn't like the love potion though, because I think they were bound to love each other regardless so it seemed unnecessary. He was heroic and had been so nice and kind to her. Plus being stuck on a boat in close quarters for THAT long...you are bound to get the feels. ;) I liked the magic, but I hated the magic love potion. I GET that it is symbolic and etc and etc, but still. 

Overall, I really adore the book. The movie is 100% better but I blame James Franco. Can't beat him hehe. But this book really does stand well on its own. Its tragic love between lovers, family, and friends. Lies, affairs, secrets, betrayals....it is the human element and it really is showed here. Love can be the most deadly and dangerous emotion. 

I highly recommend it. I still will keep the 5 stars on this one. 







Challenge(s):
- #9 for Romance Bingo - Free spot









Tuesday, March 10

Book Review: The Romance of Tristan and Iseult

Author: Joseph Bedier
Title: The Romance of Tristan and Iseult
Genre: Classic, Romance, Tragedy, & fantasy
Pages: 96
First Published: 1900
Where I Got It: My shelf (Amazon)

A tale of chivalry and doomed, transcendent love, The Romance of Tristan and Iseult is one of the most resonant works of Western literature, as well as the basis for our enduring idea of romance. The story of the Cornish knight and the Irish princess who meet by deception, fall in love by magic, and pursue that love in defiance of heavenly and earthly law


I do love my tragic romances and this has been one of my favorites since I first read it at 12 years old. Ah yes...I started my romances at a young age. The story of Tristan and Iseult is considered the inspiration of some of the most well-known romances like 'Romeo & Juliet' and 'Lancelot and Guinevere'. I do like the tale of Lancelot and Guinevere (even tho I root for Arthur to win), but I have never liked 'Romeo & Juliet'. 


"Why? It's tragic like Tristan and Iseult!" They ask.

NO! It is not...it is two little kids who knew each other for a couple weeks and decide kill themselves. I believe that a deep love comes from more then a pretty face and just wanting to "be together". While Tristan and Iseult know each other for years - try to deny their love, try to be good so they don't destroy their love's life, but their love will sooner or later destroy them. NOW THAT is tragic! 


I really love this romance and the retelling of the poetry is nice, however, I am not a fan of the "love potion" part. I feel it takes away from the element of love...because I feel like they felt love the moment Iseult saved Tristan the first time. Could be wrong, but they didn't need the potion. Maybe it made it the love more intense. 

Other then that, I do love the fantasy aspect of the story - like the dragon. I loved that scene. 

Oooooh, I am such a sap...my heart melted again for this book. I do love Tristan. But I also felt bad for King Mark...yes when he finds out that he is being betrayed by his wife and nephew he does snap, but he does make up for it later. Honestly, everything would have been fine if they didn't force King Mark to marry...he was fine with leaving Tristan is heir, but NOOOO the damn Councillors didn't like Tristan, so they forced a wife on King Mark to make an heir. Why can't anyone leave well enough alone?!

UGH!

But yes...I highly recommend this to those that like some tragic classics in their lives. I must actually finish the movie from beginning to end now. I wish that this left out the "love potion", but alas...with or without it they were doomed to love each other. Other then that, I am still in love with the story and the characters. Out of five stars, I stamp this with 5 stars; more like 4.5, but alas, I rounded.


Favorite Character(s): King Mark (even tho he loses his cool at one point), Tristan, & Iseult
Not-so Favorite Character(s): The Councillors & the dwarf (>___>)  
 Favorite Quote(s): "Love pressed them hard, as thirst presses the dying stag to the stream; love dropped upon them from high heaven, as a hawk slipped after long hunger falls right upon the bird. And love will not be hidden...But in every hour and place every man could see Love terrible, that rode them, and could see in these lovers their every sense overflowing like new wine working in the vat."